Is AI Revolutionizing Music as a Creative Partner or Posing a Threat to Artists?

The music industry has always been a landscape of innovation, creativity, and evolution. From the introduction of electric instruments to the rise of digital production, each technological advancement has reshaped how music is created, distributed, and consumed. Today, we find ourselves at the forefront of another significant shift: the rise of artificial intelligence (AI) in music. This development raises an intriguing question: Is AI a creative partner that enhances the artistic process, or does it pose a threat to the very essence of artistry?

In this blog post, we will explore the multifaceted role of AI in music, examining its potential benefits and drawbacks, and ultimately seeking to understand its impact on artists and the industry as a whole.

AI

Music before AI

In the good old days writing music was literal: you had a pencil and a sheet of paper and you were going to write down every single notes. With time some software came to the horizon to help the process and at first Sibelius was a super innovative solution and afterwards tons of software came up to speed up the writing process. Careful that I'm saying speed up not doing the job for you!

I myself use MuseScore and of course it saves tons of pencils and erasers!

But back to the topic: AI has made significant strides in various fields, and music is no exception. From algorithmic composition to AI-driven music production tools, the technology is being integrated into every aspect of the music-making process.

AI can analyze vast amounts of data, learning from existing music to create new compositions that mimic various styles and genres. This capability has led to the development of tools that can assist musicians in songwriting, arranging, and even producing tracks. And that's the trick part: AI should assist and help, not substitute your creativity.

But this goes hand in hand with other situations such as, the boom of overnight artists. What do I mean with that? Do you remember that during the beginning of Covid when no one could go out, everybody became baker, chef, content creator, writers and musicians too, although the musician part since the loops and sample came to life, have created lots of " musicians", but that's more for another post.

So as AI continues to evolve, it raises questions about creativity, originality, and the role of the artist.

Enhanced Creativity?

In theory one of the most significant advantages of AI in music is its ability to enhance creativity. AI tools can generate ideas, suggest chord progressions, and even create melodies that artists might not have considered. I tried to use AI for lyrics and music and the results were kind of ugly, or at least very far from my idea of composing music: random words very superficial, and music kind of blah.

These tools should only serve as a source of inspiration, helping artists break through creative blocks and in case explore new musical territories that normally would be off limits.

Streamlined Production Processes

AI should make the music process more efficient and accessible. With AI-driven software, musicians can automate repetitive tasks, such as mixing and mastering, allowing them to focus on the creative aspects of their work. It doesn't take a genius that this part can easily be abused, meaning becoming lazy and let AI doing all the job in the name of producing tons of music, hoping that one tune could go viral.

The efficiency could be particularly beneficial for independent artists who may not have access to professional studios or resources. By leveraging AI, they can produce high-quality music without the need for extensive technical knowledge or expensive equipment. But what happen to the old say "if it sounds good is good "? Why should I need AI to tell me that something is good, good according to who?

Of course people can think that my music sucks but it's a personal opinion and if someone doesn't like it maybe someone else will love it.

Of course AI is a data analyzer and if most of the people for example like rap most likely they won't like my music.

Personalized Music Experiences

AI is also transforming how listeners engage with music. Streaming platforms like Spotify and Apple Music use AI algorithms to analyze user preferences and create personalized playlists.

This level of customization enhances the listening experience, allowing users to discover new artists and genres that align with their tastes. For musicians, this means greater exposure and the potential to reach wider audiences. And here we have another bit BUT: discover new artists pushed by labels or REALLY discover new artists, posssibly independent? If you have an answer let me know!

Questions of Authenticity

While AI offers numerous benefits, it also raises concerns about authenticity and originality. If a machine can create music that sounds indistinguishable from that of human artists, what does that mean for the value of human creativity? Plus if AI basically collect data from artists, chances are that the music it produces is somehow a collection of others ( to make it simple!) so what is the real difference with being inspired by listening to music?

Some argue that music created by AI lacks the emotional depth and personal experiences that human artists bring to their work. This raises the questions probably rhetorical: Can AI truly understand the nuances of human emotion? In my opinion no it can't! Is it merely mimicking patterns it has learned from existing music? In my opinion yes!

Job Displacement?

Another significant concern is the potential for job displacement within the music industry. As AI tools become more advanced, there is a fear that they could replace certain roles traditionally held by musicians, producers, and sound engineers.

For instance, if AI can compose music, will there still be a demand for songwriters? Will producers be needed if AI can mix and master tracks with precision? These questions highlight the potential economic implications of AI in music, particularly for those whose livelihoods depend on their artistic skills. And this consideration embraces not only the music field. IN some area probably is something needed but when creativity is involved I think that human touch is always the best solution.

The Risk of Homogenization

And everything goes in circle and the fact that AI rely on data and algorithms can also lead to a risk of homogenization in music. If AI is trained on existing music, it may produce compositions that sound similar to what is already out there, stifling innovation and diversity.

This concern is particularly relevant in an industry that thrives on originality and unique voices. If AI-generated music becomes the norm, will we lose the rich tapestry of diverse sounds and styles that characterize the music landscape? After all all the big innovations happened because some schemes got broken not because someone repeated the same stuff and got lucky.

Collaboration Over Competition

Rather than viewing AI as a competitor, many artists are beginning to embrace it as a collaborator. By integrating AI into their creative processes, musicians can leverage its capabilities while still maintaining their artistic vision. For example if my weak part of the music making is mixing and mastering I welcome AI to help me but probably I welcome the training part to make me understand how it works not doing the job for me.

Maybe I'm old fashioned but I feel a great gratification when I can accomplish a good final product and where would go all the joy if someone else does the job for me? It wouldn't feel like my creation.

This collaborative approach allows artists to push the boundaries of their creativity, exploring new sounds and ideas that they may not have discovered on their own. And this should be the goal. But of course I speak as trained musician not as someone that woke up one day saying " I want to make music " without having any knowledge or skills.

Emphasizing Human Emotion

To counteract the, let's call it, potential threats posed by AI, artists can focus on what makes their music uniquely human: emotion, storytelling, and personal experiences. By infusing their work with authenticity and vulnerability, musicians can create a connection with their audience that AI simply cannot replicate.

This emphasis on human emotion can serve as a powerful differentiator in a landscape increasingly populated by AI-generated music.

The Future of Music Creation

As we look to the future, it is clear that AI will continue to play a significant role in the music industry. However, the key to navigating this new landscape lies in finding a balance between technology and human creativity.

The AI revolution in music presents both exciting opportunities and significant challenges for artists. While AI has the potential to enhance creativity, streamline production processes, and personalize music experiences, it also raises important questions about authenticity, job displacement, and the risk of homogenization.

Ultimately, the future of music creation will depend on how artists choose to engage with AI. By viewing it as a creative partner rather than a threat, musicians can leverage its capabilities to push the boundaries of their artistry while maintaining the emotional depth and authenticity that define their work.

Maybe, I'm just throwing an idea there, with AI it will be more evident the differences between trained and skilled musicians and people that use tools and softwares to make music without the basic knowledge: so maybe, always maybe, it's not a bad thing but I'm not sure how a human feeling could be replaced by a stream of bites.

If you like what you read don't forget to subscribe to my blog

Subscribe